What makes for a good protagonist in fiction? Is a good protagonist necessarily synonymous with a good hero? If not, then what's the difference? And who are some of your favorite protagonists in fiction?
| Author | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Violanthe |
Protagonists |
Lead | |
|
What makes for a good protagonist in fiction? Is a good protagonist necessarily synonymous with a good hero? If not, then what's the difference? And who are some of your favorite protagonists in fiction? |
|||
saundrakane |
|||
|
I actually like a protagonist that is a little marginal...good but with human quirks. Harry Bosch is the Michael Connelly series is one example. He is
basically a good guy but constantly breaks the rules and is in trouble with his superiors. And he has terrible luck in relationships.
|
|||
Violanthe |
|||
|
Well, practically every protagonist in popular culture has terrible luck in relationships.
|
|||
saundrakane |
|||
|
I think that is because we love our heroes to be single and free and available for any adventure that comes along.
|
|||
AirPrang |
|||
|
Ian Rankin's Inspector John Rebus: deeply flawed, a bit of a maverick, but ultimately dead straight as far as policing goes. (And also very unattractive as
a romantic interest!)
|
|||
sublimosa |
|||
|
well, he has to have some man vs. himself going on as well as external conflict
I don't want him or her to be a total loner. It drives me crazy when characters have absolutely no friends/relatives. I don't want a Dirk Pitt of Clive Cussler fame. (For those of you fortunate enough to have missed him-he is perfect. He always wins every outrageous battle, no matter what the odds. He always always always gets the girl. I'll let Roger Moore's James Bond slide by all that, but no one else!) A well developed antagonist? A sense of humor, personal insigh, hese are good... I don't think the hero and protagonist have to be the same, but I'm having a hard time coming up with examples. I can definitely say what makes a bad hero/protagonist, and that is the all perfect, all knowing, all winning character. As a teen, I loved Edgar Rice Burroughs' John Carter of Mars. I reread three of the books last year and I was intensely bored. Yes, he faced challenges, but there was no change, no growth. I kept wishing for his body to adjust to the Mars atmosphere. At least he had a friend! |
|||
Violanthe |
|||
|
What loner characters have you read and disliked in the past?
|
|||
sublimosa |
|||
|
Violet, it's not necessarily that I don't LIKE loner characters. I guess I am prone to feeling depressed
at how starkly lonely (amid all the other tragedies) the character is feeling. Perhaps I'm projecting and should say how lonely I'd be feeling.
Although I "like" Rebus, he's a good example. (Only read a few of the books so far but from what I read on here his circumstances don't change.) I'm having memory issues again (ha ha) so I'll have to use some shameful examples (please don't think less of me!!) I read A LOT OF Harlequin romances from my early teens into my twenties and they are chock full of the loner heroine. The dumb girl was almost always an orphan and she had no real friends-often she didn't have ANY friends. If I can come up with some legitimate examples from some more solid literature, I'll be back. = ) |
|||
Golophin |
|||
|
A good protagonist for me has to be someone i can get emotionally invlolved with for example Jon Snow, Severian the Lame, Boromir of Gondor or the main
character in the True History of the Siege of Lisbon. A hero i can enjoy reading their exploits but its not neccasery that i identify with them for example
Sherlock Holmes, Dirk Pitt, Aragon or James Bond.
|
|||
Islandgirl81 |
|||
|
Digressing a little, but I agree with sublimosa on how ridiculous the "loner heroines" of Harlequin Romances were. They were always supposed to be
these sweet, lovely women who, inexplicably, had absolutely NO friends nor any relatives they were particularly close to. However, I'm going to disagree
with AirPrang about Rankin's John Rebus being "very unattractive" as a romantic interest. I actually think he's rather appealing, in a
world-weary sort of way.
Last Edited By: Islandgirl81
06/29/09 07:37.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
AirPrang |
|||
No worries, you can have him. Would you want to be in a relationship with him though? I've been re-reading the books where he's with Dr Patience
Aitken, and she's more than living up to her name.
Seriously though, he is appealing on some levels but I think I'd settle for being friends. It'd be a lot less frustrating. Good point about those romance heroines. I'd never thought of that, but their lack of friends and wider social circle does seem at odds with their supposed character. |
|||